A Lodge livestream "I call" is ruled a call, and the $28,000 pot is chopped
Facing an $8,700 river shove on a Nov 5 Poker at the Lodge stream, a player known as Justin said "I gotta go anyway. I call," pushed chips forward, then pulled them back when his opponent started to show and said he hadn't called. The floor ruled it a call and the two hands chopped. Skull Mike's clip of the hand has passed 1.9 million views on X.

A cash-game hand on the Nov 5 Poker at the Lodge livestream has been one of the most talked-about poker clips on X this week. A player known on the stream as Justin said "I call" out loud, pushed his chips forward, then pulled them back when his opponent started to show and said he hadn't called. The floor ruled it a call, and the two hands chopped the pot, according to PokerNews and Poker.org.
Stream commentator Skull Mike, who was also playing in the game, posted the video on Nov 9. By Thursday morning it had passed 1.9 million views, by X's count. The Lodge Card Club, the Texas card room co-owned by Doug Polk, Brad Owen and Andrew Neeme per PokerNews, shared it too and asked: "An angle or just an honest mistake?"
The hand
- Turn: the board was 8♠ 10♠ 10♦ 8♣ with $6,460 in the pot. San Kim, holding A♥9♠, bet $2,500 and Justin called with A♦K♥, per PokerNews.
- River: the 6♣. Both players had the same hand, tens and eights with an ace kicker, so it was a chop from here unless someone folded.
- Kim, the bigger stack, moved all in for $8,700. That made the final pot about $28,000, per PokerNews; by our math from those numbers, $28,860 once the call went in.
What was said at the table
Justin went into the tank and started talking, per Poker.org: "Oh, I don't know if I can beat you or not, I got ace-high here. Can you beat ace-high?" Kim stayed quiet. Justin then said "I gotta go anyway," grabbed a stack, pushed it forward and said "I call."
Kim began to turn his cards over, and Justin pulled his chips back. "I didn't call," he said. Another player at the table, Jay Nguyen, told him: "You said, 'I call'." Justin answered: "I said I gotta go anyway." The floor came over and ruled that he had called; both hands were shown and the pot was split.
What the rules say
Each card room sets its own house rules, but the principle the floor applied is standard. In the Poker Tournament Directors Association's 2024 rules, used by many tournaments, Rule 51-A says: "General verbal declarations in turn (such as 'call' or 'raise') commit a player to the full current action." Rule 50-A says action in turn, verbal and/or by pushing out chips, "is binding." Rule 40-A covers bets made both ways: whichever comes first defines the bet.
Here both happened. Justin said "I call" in turn, facing a bet, and pushed chips forward. Either one on its own is normally enough for a call.
Reaction, and a defense from the commentator
The replies were harsh. Poker.org collected posts calling for a ban from the stream, and PokerNews quoted others calling it "awful etiquette." A lot of players also pointed out that he gained nothing by it: with the hands tied, the pot was always going to be split if he called.
Skull Mike, who sat next to him, posted a defense the next day: "contrary to popular belief, Justin is a genuinely good man. He simply got caught up in the moment when San reacted quickly and honestly forgot that he had verbalized a call. In game, sitting right next to him, I did not hear him announce it during the hand either. With the video, it's clear he did." He added that "whether he said 'call' out loud is beside the point, as the forward motion of his chips while facing a bet was sufficient to support the correct ruling."
As of Thursday morning, neither The Lodge nor the stream had said publicly whether he will play on the stream again.
The takeaway for your own game
Treat "call" as a final word. If you aren't sure yet, say nothing and keep your hands off your chips until you've decided. And if a player across the table says "call" and then tries to take it back, don't argue it out yourself: call the floor, the way Kim and the rest of the table did here.
Sources
- X: @SkullMikePoker, video of the hand ("You're not gonna believe this one"), Nov 9, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- X: @SkullMikePoker, follow-up on the player and the ruling, Nov 10, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- X: @LodgePokerClub, "An angle or just an honest mistake?" (video), Nov 10, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- PokerNews: Jon Sofen, Poker Player Makes a Blatant Angle-Shoot Only to Chop the Pot (cards, bet sizes, floor ruling), Nov 10, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Poker.org: Dave Woods, 'Ban this clown' - Poker player slammed over livestream angle shoot (Nov 5 stream, dialogue at the table), Nov 11, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Poker TDA 2024 Rules, Version 1.0 (Rules 40, 50 and 51-A on verbal declarations and acting in turn), Oct 9, 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- Lodge Card Club: clubs in Round Rock (Austin) and San Antonio, Texas (opens in a new tab)
What changed
- Published.
The Thursday email
What changed at the sites we cover and in state law, with a source for every item. If nothing changed, we say so in one line. Promos only when we've read the terms and they hold up.


